Critique Sample

Working Title/Artist: Walker Evans: Subway Department:  Culture/Period/Location:  HB/TOA Date Code:  Working Date:  photography by mma, Digital File DP109864.tif retouched by film and media (jnc) 3_16_10

Working Title/Artist: Walker Evans: Subway
HB/TOA Date Code:
Working Date:
photography by mma, Digital File DP109864.tif
retouched by film and media (jnc) 3_16_10


The image takes place in a subway train full of people. A man wearing a suit and jacket stands in the middle of the subway aisle. He plays the accordion and looks to be singing. His eyes are half closed. He has an enamel cup tied on a string hanging from the instrument. The people sitting in the seats are mostly Caucasian men wearing coats and hats. On the left side of the image, two men from different depths field are looking toward the camera. On the right side of the image, one man in close depth of field sits reading the paper. Although the subway is packed, no one appears to be looking at the accordion player.

Formal Analysis

The one point perspective of the camera in line with the subject emphasises the subway space. The accordion with a cup hanging off it with string is in focus that emphasises its shape and folded texture. This folded texture is repeated by the seated man holding an open newspaper. Like the accordion, the newspaper is more in focus as these objects lie on the same plane. The faces of both men are out of focus and their eyes are lidded, each absorbed in their own worlds.


The photographer captures a scene of isolation even though the subject is singing and playing the accordion on a full subway. The player’s eyes are closed, his head tilted slightly back, and he appears lost in his song. The fact that he is wearing a suit and jacket seems in contrast to the begging cup hanging off his accordion, and suggests an act of desperation. The theme of seclusion is emphasized by the man reading a newspaper, his head and eyes cast downward, apparently absorbed in the news of the day. Perhaps the accordion player’s song draws the other subway passengers into their own worlds, but the overall tone of the photograph depicts a scene of social disengagement.

Posted in Critique.

Critique vs Criticism

Critique is a description, analysis, and reflection of an image.

Criticism is finding fault in an image.

To critique, say:

“The image…” or “The photographer…” or use one the Principles and Elements of Art, such as, “The element of line is thin and vertical in the image.”

Avoid saying, “I like…” or “I don’t like…”. This says something about you, and nothing about the image.

Use the Principles and Elements of Art Chart to help critique photographs.


Posted in Critique.

Photography Class Survey

Please fill out the anonymous online survey.

Posted in Uncategorized.

Student Examples of Light and Shadow


Light & Shadow: Camille



Light & Shadow: Jason



Light & Shadow: Junelia



Light & Shadow: Junelia



Light & Shadow: Mary Joy



Light & Shadow: Palak



Posted in Light & Shadow Examples.

Student Examples of Texture


Texture: Alyssa


Texture: Camille



Texture: Edlyn



Texture: Jason



Texture: Julius



Texture: Kelvin



Texture: Manisha



Texture: Rachel



Texture: Samson



Posted in Texture Examples.

How To Submit Work


How to submit your finished work:

  • Save your files as two types
    1. 300 dpi .jpg or working CS4 file (PS or AI) as lastname_firstname_assignment.jpg for marking and printing.
    2. 72 dpi .jpg file as lastname_firstname_assignment.jpg for blog.
  • Submit your high resolution file to: SDrive>Handin>Nelson_Photo>”assignment type”
Posted in Submission.

Student Blogs ~ Composition

Great blogs to visit to find out more about this assignment:

Posted in Photography Assignments.

Erik Johansson ~ Surreal Photographer

Video by: Erik Johansson

Posted in Photographers.

We Got Blogs


Posted in Look-ee Blogs.
Skip to toolbar